In general one would not expect a close correlation between the nanoscience and nanomaterials R&D leading to near-term applications in medicine, energy, computation, and other fields, and the molecular nanotechnology that will eventually lead to productive nanosystems and atomically precise manufacturing. A counter example in which the correlation is looking close is structural DNA nanotechnology. A hat tip to KurzweilAI for showcasing this news release from Harvard’s Wyss Institute “Cloaked DNA nanodevices survive pilot mission“:
It’s a familiar trope in science fiction: In enemy territory, activate your cloaking device. And real-world viruses use similar tactics to make themselves invisible to the immune system. Now scientists at Harvard’s Wyss Institute for Biologically Inspired Engineering have mimicked these viral tactics to build the first DNA nanodevices that survive the body’s immune defenses.
The results pave the way for smart DNA nanorobots that could use logic to diagnose cancer earlier and more accurately than doctors can today; target drugs to tumors, or even manufacture drugs on the spot to cripple cancer, the researchers report in the April 22 online issue of ACS Nano [abstract, PDF available].
“We’re mimicking virus functionality to eventually build therapeutics that specifically target cells,” said Wyss Institute Core Faculty member William Shih, Ph.D., the paper’s senior author. Shih is also an Associate Professor of Biological Chemistry and Molecular Pharmacology at Harvard Medical School and Associate Professor of Cancer Biology at the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute.
The same cloaking strategy could also be used to make artificial microscopic containers called protocells that could act as biosensors to detect pathogens in food or toxic chemicals in drinking water.
DNA is well known for carrying genetic information, but Shih and other bioengineers are using it instead as a building material. To do this, they use DNA origami — a method Shih helped extend from 2D to 3D. In this method, scientists take a long strand of DNA and program it to fold into specific shapes, much as a single sheet of paper is folded to create various shapes in the traditional Japanese art.
Shih’s team assembles these shapes to build DNA nanoscale devices that might one day be as complex as the molecular machinery found in cells. For example, they are developing methods to build DNA into tiny robots that sense their environment, calculate how to respond, then carry out a useful task, such as performing a chemical reaction or generating mechanical force or movement.
Such DNA nanorobots may themselves sound like science fiction, but they already exist. In 2012 Wyss Institute researchers reported in Science that they had built a nanorobot that uses logic to detect a target cell, then reveals an antibody that activates a “suicide switch” in leukemia or lymphoma cells.
For a DNA nanodevice to successfully diagnose or treat disease, it must survive the body’s defenses long enough to do its job. But Shih’s team discovered that DNA nanodevices injected into the bloodstream of mice are quickly digested.
“That led us to ask, ‘How could we protect our particles from getting chewed up?'” Shih said.
Nature inspired the solution. The scientists designed their nanodevices to mimic a type of virus that protects its genome by enclosing it in a solid protein case, then layering on an oily coating identical to that in membranes that surround living cells. That coating, or envelope, contains a double layer (bilayer) of phospholipid that helps the viruses evade the immune system and delivers them to the cell interior.
“We suspected that a virus-like envelope around our particles could solve our problem,” Shih said.
To coat DNA nanodevices with phospholipid, Steve Perrault, Ph.D., a Wyss Institute Technology Development fellow in Shih’s group and the paper’s lead author, first folded DNA into a virus-sized octahedron. Then, he took advantage of the precision-design capabilities of DNA nanotechnology, building in handles to hang lipids, which in turn directed the assembly of a single bilayer membrane surrounding the octahedron.
Under an electron microscope, the coated nanodevices closely resembled an enveloped virus.
Perrault then demonstrated that the new nanodevices survived in the body. He did that by loading them with fluorescent dye, injecting them into mice, and using whole-body imaging to see what parts of the mouse glowed.
Just the bladder glowed in mice that received uncoated nanodevices, which meant that the animals broke them down quickly and were ready to excrete their contents. But the animals’ entire body glowed for hours when they received the new, coated nanodevices. This showed that nanodevices remained in the bloodstream as long as effective drugs do.
The coated devices also evade the immune system. Levels of two immune-activating molecules were at least 100-fold lower in mice treated with coated nanodevices as opposed to uncoated nanodevices.
In the future, cloaked nanorobots could activate the immune system to fight cancer or suppress the immune system to help transplanted tissue become established.
“Activating the immune response could be useful clinically or it might be something to avoid,” Perrault said. “The main point is that we can control it.”
“Patients with cancer and other diseases would benefit enormously from precise, molecular-scale tools to simultaneously diagnose and treat diseased tissues, and making DNA nanoparticles last in the body is a huge step in that direction,” said Wyss Institute Founding Director Don Ingber, M.D., Ph.D.
Many types of nanoparticles have been proposed and tested as drug delivery vehicles, including lipids, polymers, lipopeptides, and gold nanoparticles. Of these, structural DNA nanotechnology offers perhaps the greatest potential due to capability of building ever more complex atomically precise molecular devices. This work has addressed perhaps the greatest limitations of this approach: degradation and immunogenicity in the animal body. Lipid-conjugated oligonucleotides were placed with atomic precision on the outer face of the central DNA nano-octahedron to guide the assembly of the protective lipid envelope. The 50-nm diameter DNA nano-octahedron used for this work may provide a starting point for building more complex functional nanodevices. The authors’ concluding remarks show that they are thinking in that direction.
A more distant but highly exciting prospect is the development of autonomous devices having functions approaching that of virus particles (eg., cell entry via attachment and fusion) or primitive immune cells (eg.,input-based therapeutic response), and which could provide significant advances in diagnostics and therapeutics.
Although the focus of such goals is incremental progress in nanomedicine, the challenges that workers pursing these goals will face may jump-start the development of molecular systems engineering sophisticated enough to also make possible productive nanosystems (molecular manufacturing, or in the currently popular terminology, atomically precise manufacturing).
—James Lewis, PhD
